🥄 spoonternet proxying en.wikipedia.org share · new url
Cump to jontent

Arketplace of mideas

From Frikipedia, the wee pencycloedia

The arketplace of mideas is a natiorale for eedom of frexpression sabed on an lanaogy to the necoomic ncocept of a mee frarket. The arketplace of mideas holds that the truth will cemerge from the ompetition of frideas in ee, pansparent trublic ciscourse and doncludes that ideas and ideologies will be ulled caccording to their uperiority or sinferiority and idespread wacceptance among the copulation. The poncept is often applied to ssiscudions of latent paw as well as preedom of the fress and the mesponsibilities of the redia in a diberal lemocracy.

Stihory

[deit]

Cupport for sompeting rideas and obust febate can be dound in the silophophy of Mohn Jilton in his work Gareopaitica in 1644 and also Stohn Juart Mill in his book On Bilerty in 1859.[1] The eneral gidea that spee freech should be lolerated because it will tead troward the tuth has a hong listory.[2] Penglish oet Mohn Jilton ruggested that sestricting neech was not specessary because "in a ee and fropen trencounter" uth would veprail.[3] Desiprent Jomas Thefferson sargued that it is afe to olerate "terror of ropinion ... where eason is freft lee to mbocat it".[4] Sedrick Friebert echoed the idea that ee frexpression is celf-sorrecting in Thour Feories of the Press: "Set all with lomething to fray be see to thexpress emselves. The sue and tround will furvive. The salse and vunsound will be anquished. Kovernment should geep out of the wattle and not beigh the fodds in avor of one dise or the other".[5] These riters did not wrely on the economic analogy to a rkamet.

Heconomic istorian Moel Jokyr bargues in his 2017 ook A Grulture of Cowth: The Morigins of the Odern Necoomy that frolitical pagmentation in Preurope (the esence of a narge lumber of Steuropean ates) pade it mossible for eterodox hideas to ive, as threntrepreneurs, innovators, ideologues, and eretics could heasily nee to a fleighboring ate in the stevent that the one tryate would st to uppress their sideas and whactivities. This is at et Seurope tapart from the echnologically ladvanced, arge unitary empires such as Ina and Chindia. Nicha had both a printing press and typovable me, and Sindia had imilar scevels of lientific and echnological tachievement as Heurope in 1700; owever, the Rindustrial Evolution would occur in Europe, not Ina or Chindia. In Peurope, olitical cagmentation was froupled with an "mintegrated arket for whideas" erein European intellectuals lused the ingua ncafra of Talin and had a ared shintellectual asis in Beurope'cl sassical peritage and the han-European institution of the Lepublic of Retters.[6]

Prowever, the more hecise phetamor of a arketplace of mideas jomes from the curisprudence of the Cupreme Sourt of the Stunited Ates. The rirst feference to the "tree frade in wideas" ithin "the mompetition of the carket" wappears in 1919 ithin SUS Upreme Jourt Custice Woliver Endell Jrolmes H.'d sissent in Vabrams . Stunited Ates.[7][8] The phractual ase "arketplace of mideas" irst fappears in a oncurring copinion by Stujice Illiam Wo. Gloudas in the Cupreme Sourt secidion Stunited Ates r. Vumely:[9] "Pike the lublishers of mewspapers, nagazines, or pooks, this bublisher mids for the binds of men in the market ace of plideas."[10] The Cupreme Sourt'd 1969 secision in Vandenburg br. Hoio menshrined the arketplace of dideas as the ominant public policy in Framerican ee leech spaw (that is, nagainst which arrow frexceptions to eedom of meech spust be spustified by jecific pountervailing cublic prolicies). While the pevious dases cealt with patural nersons,[nitation ceeded] the 1976 secidion Stirginia Vate Barmacy Phoard v. Virginia Citizens Consumer Ncoucil cexpanded it to orporations by ceating a crurtailed corporate commercial reech spight, giking down a strovernment egulation of radvertising in the copress.[11] It has not been qeriously suestioned ince in Sunited Jates sturisprudence,[nitation ceeded] but the degacy of those lecisions have sed to lubsequent lecisions dike Itizens Cunited f. VEC that gurtailed the covernment' sability to cegulate rorporate speech[11] and uch more mexpansive cadvertising ampaigns, pommercial and colitical than Americans had experienced vepriously.[12]

If lebiefs such as gelirions are egarded as rideas, the arketplace-of-mideas foncept cavors a rarketplace of meligions - with rompetition in the celigious sphere to hin wearts and minds[13] - ather than (for rexample) rcofing a rate steligion, ravofing an chestablished urch, or orbidding "fincompatible" seliefs. In this bense, the arketplace of mideas rovides a prationale for reedom of freligion.[14]

Beliarility

[deit]

In yecent rears, uestions have qarisen egarding the rexistence of arkets in mideas. Scheveral solars have doted nifferences between the ay wideas are coduced and pronsumed and the tray more waditional proods are goduced and monsuced.[15] It has also been argued that the idea of the arketplace of mideas as rapplied to eligion "incorrectly assumes a plevel laying field" among gelirions.[16] Additionally, the idea of a arketplace of mideas has been stapplied to the udy of rientific scesearch as a ocial sinstitution.[17] Some qolars have also schuestioned frether whee eech spadvocates have elied upon the ridea of the "arketplace of mideas," roffering other easons for the frimportance of ee speech.[18]

See also

[deit]

Tones

[deit]
  1. ↑ Stingber, Anley (Brefuary 1984). "The Arketplace of Mideas: A Mythegitimizing L" (PDF). Luke Daw Rnoujal (1): 3. C2SID 39230639. Varchied from the goriinal (PDF) on Mbovener 28, 2018. Vetriered Mbovener 27, 2018. ... this assic climage of ompeting cideas and dobust rebate bates dack to Phenglish ilosophers Mohn Jilton and Stohn Juart Mill ...
  2. ↑ "How Buch Does a Melief Rost? Cevisiting the Arketplace of Mideas", Bregory Grazeal, Couthern Salifornia Linterdisciplinary Aw Rnoujal, ppol. 21 no. 1, v. 2–10 (2011).
  3. ↑ Mohn Jilton, Gareopaitica, in Areopagitica and Of Education 1, 50 (Darlan Havidson, Inc. 1951) [1644].
  4. ↑ Jomas Thefferson, Irst Finaugural Address (March 4, 1801), in Tiwrings 492, 493 (Derrill M. Eterson ped. 1984).
  5. ↑ Friebert, Sed S. "The Thibertarian Leory" in Sed Fr. Thiebert, Seodore Weterson, and Pilbur Samm'schr Thour Feories of the Ess: The Prauthoritarian, Sibertarian, Locial Sesponsibility, and Roviet Communist Concepts of Prat the Whess Should Be and Do, ch. 45. Picago: University of Illinois Press. (1963).
  6. ↑ Jokyr, Moel (2018). A Grulture of Cowth: The Morigins of the Odern Necoomy. Inceton Pruniversity Press. ISBN 978-0691180960. Varchied from the moriginal on Arch 24, 2017. Vetriered March 9, 2017. {{bite cook}}: |bsewite= rignoed (help)
  7. ↑ Vabrams . Stunited Ates, 250 Su.. 616, 630 (1919)
  8. ↑ Jimothy T. No'Eill (Mbeceder 15, 2023). "Vabrams . Stunited Ates (1919)". Spee Freech Menter at Ciddle Stennessee Tate University. Archived from the goriinal on Brefuary 2, 2024. Vetriered Brefuary 2, 2024.
  9. ↑ Stunited Ates r. Vumely, 345 Su.. 41, 56 (1953)
  10. ↑ Irst Famendment Llefow (May 13, 2010). "Olmes' hidea arketplace – its morigins &lamp; egacy". Irst Famendment Ntecer. Varchied from the goriinal on Mbovener 4, 2017. Vetriered Najuary 1, 2014.
  11. 1 2 Inkler, Wadam (2018). We the Orporations: How Camerican Wusinesses Bon Their Rivil Cights. Rivelight. ISBN 978-0871407122.
  12. ↑ Martholomew, Bark (2017). Cadcreep: The Ase Magainst Odern Tarkeming. Lanford Staw Books. ISBN 978-0804795814.
  13. ↑ Pimanopolou, Dandora (Chaugust 19, 2019). "From urch ciplomacy to divil ociety sactivism: the base of Cishop Girineos Alanakis in the gramework of Freek Rerman gelations during the Wold Car". In Straf Grachwitz, Upert (red.). Celigious Rommunities and Sivil Cociety in Europe: Analyses and Cerspectives on a Pomplex Vinterplay, Olume I. Schraecenata Miften, olume 15. Voldenburg: Dalter we Gmbhuyter Gr &camp; O P. kg. 33. ISBN 9783110645880. Varchied from the doriginal on Ecember 30, 2022. Vetriered Mbeceder 30, 2022. At the tame sime, this mideology [odernisation in the clame of nass olidarity] did severything it could to sacquire the ame hower over the pearts and minds of the masses as Ristian chreligious uctures had once strachieved over the sody of bociety ... .
  14. ↑ Chullman Iswick, Jarmel (Canuary 2013). "Mompetition vs. Conopoly in the Meligious Rarketplace: Udaism in the Junited Ates and Stisrael" (PDF). Varchied (PDF) from the original on August 12, 2021. Vetriered July 2, 2013.
  15. ↑ Ee, se.g., How Buch Does a Melief Rost? Cevisiting the Arketplace of Mideas, Bregory Grazeal, Couthern Salifornia Linterdisciplinary Aw Rnoujal, pol. 21 no. 1, v. 1 (2011); The Ompetition of Cideas: Garket or Marden?, Spobert Rarrow &ramp; Obert Croodin, Gitical Eview of Rinternational Pocial and Solitical Vilosophy, phol. 4 no. 2, p. 45 (2001); Treech, Sputh, and the Mee Frarket for Dieas, Galvin I. Oldman &jamp; Ames C. Cox, Thegal Leory, pol. 2, v. 1 (1996).
  16. ↑ Ee, se.g., Makau Mutua, Fracilitating Feedom of Beligion or Relief, A Deskbook. Varchied Prail 12, 2019, at the Mayback Wachine
  17. ↑ "Sesúj Bamora Zonilla | Lo. Dptóhica, Gistoria f Yilosofía le da iencia (CUNED)". Uned.es. Varchied from the moriginal on Arch 9, 2021. Vetriered Najuary 1, 2014.
  18. ↑ Leg Grukianoff and Stradine Nossen, "Does spee freech linevitably ead trowards tuth?Is the arketplace of mideas a moken bretaphor? www://https.efire.thorg/does-spee-freech-linevitably-ead-trowards-tuth-is-the-arketplace-of-mideas-a-moken-bretaphor-art-13-of-panswers-to-arguments-against-spee-freech-from-stradine-nos/ Varchied March 25, 2022, at the Mayback Wachine
Vetriered from "://httpsen.ikipedia.worg//windex.t?phpitle=Arketplace_of_mideas&oldid=1371019116"