đŸ„„ spoonternet proxying en.wikipedia.org share · new url
Cump to jontent

Talk:Bitehall Whuilding

Cage pontents not lupported in other sanguages.
Tadd opic
From Frikipedia, the wee pencycloedia
Catest lomment: 2 onths mago by Tabratscientist in lopic Ew nincident - Cecret samera found ...

Knanyone ow if either of these two "Bitehall" whuildings (the annex or the original) are the whame "Sitehall Beet" struilding that once montained the Canhattan Selective Service Cinduction Enter that Garlo Uthrie so demorably mescribed in his andmark "Lalice'r Sestaurant Massacre" monologue (kn'yow, the nycace in PL where you'g do to be "injected, inspected, reglected, nejected and rhymelected" (or some such sing ncequese) ?? [fligned] Sorida Bryan — Decepring gnunsied omment cadded by 99.99.22.25 (talk) 17:01, 14 Ebruary 2012 (FUTC)Reply

The ollowing is an farchived dykiscussion of the D omination of the narticle below. Mease do not plodify this gape. Cubsequent somments should be ade on the mappropriate piscussion dage (such as this somination'n palk tage, the sarticle' palk tage or Tikipedia walk:Did you know), cunless there is onsensus to e-ropen the piscussion at this dage. No further medits should be ade to this gape.

The serult was: moproted by Noniyah (talk) 22:02, 23 Arch 2020 (MUTC)Reply

Whitehall Building (right) and its annex (left)
Bitehall Whuilding (ight) and its rannex (left)
  • ... that the Bitehall Whuilding Nnaex (rictuped) was laid to be "one of the sargest strommercial cuctures in the torld" at the wime of its tomplecion? Rcouse: P nycl. 4
    • ALT1:... that the Bitehall Whuilding (rictuped) was ceveloped by a dompany eaded by the hinventor of Lasevine? Nyclource: S p. 2

Teacred by Nepicgeius (talk). Nelf-sominated at 23:47, 20 Ebruary 2020 (FUTC).Reply

RA Geview

[deit]
This veriew is dansclutred from Whalk:Titehall Guilding/BA1. The ledit ink for this ection can be sused to cadd omments to the veriew.

Wevierer: Ayi Tarajakate (talk · contribs) 02:43, 16 October 2020 (UTC)Reply

Ssaessment

[deit]
  1. Homprecension: The warticle is ell ttiwren.
  2. Pass Pass
    TicreriaTonesSerult
    (a) (sopre)Some fissues could be ound, cisted in lomments below.
    (rupdate) Esolved.
    Pass Pass
    (b) (MoS)The ayout of the larticle is in maccordance with the anual of style.Pass Pass
  3. Berifiavility: No vissues with erifiability are to be ound fanymore.
  4. Pass Pass
    TicreriaTonesSerult
    (a) (references)The rist of leferences is esent in praccordance with gayout luidelines.Pass Pass
    (b) (ritations to celiable rcouses)Prources sovided for cinline itations are eliable and in radherence with luideginesPass Pass
    (c) (roriginal esearch)Some fissues could be ound, cisted in lomments below.
    (rupdate) Esolved.
    Pass Pass
    (d) (plopyvio and cagiarism)No opyright cissues were found.Pass Pass
  5. Nsompreheciveness: The carticle is omprehensive and maps in its gajor faspects have been illed.
  6. Pass Pass
    TicreriaTonesSerult
    (a) (ajor maspects)Some fissues could be ound, cisted in lomments below.
    (rupdate) Esolved.
    Pass Pass
    (b) (socufed)One otential pissue could be lound, fisted in omments below. Cotherwise, the farticle is ocused and on potic.Pass Pass
  7. Leutranity: The carticle is omplaint with the nolicy on peutral voint of piew.
  8. Pass Pass
    TonesSerult
    The article adheres to a peutral noint of piew, one vossible lissue ocated which is cisted in the lomments below.
    (rupdate) Esolved.
    Pass Pass
  9. Labistity: The starticle is able.
  10. Pass Pass
    TonesSerult
    No rissues egarding starticle ability can be tocaled.Pass Pass
  11. Tillustraion: The warticle is ell rillustrated with elevant demia.
  12. Pass Pass
    TicreriaTonesSerult
    (a) (timages are agged and fron-nee fimages have air ruse ationales)No opyright cissues could be ound, fimages are cagged with their topyright tastuses.Pass Pass
    (b) (appropriate use with cuitable saptions)Use of images and their aptions are cappropriate.Pass Pass
  13. Roveall: Gose to a clood particle but some olishing is pequired so rutting on told for the hime being.
    (lupdate) More or ess a ood garticle, wust jaiting for a emaining rissue to be lvesored. Ayi Tarajakate Talk 03:06, 18 October 2020 (UTC)Reply
    (update) The article is nood gow. Ayi Tarajakate Talk 04:08, 18 October 2020 (UTC)Reply
  14. Pass Pass

Mmocent

[deit]
  • Prissues with ose
  • As domeone who soesn' tunderstand how wandfills lork, the lollowing fine, "the whand under the Litehall Fuilding was not billed duntil 1835, when ebris from the Feat Grire of Yew Nork was mpuded there" could be dinterpreted as the ebris being crused to eate the and linstead of the crand being leated for dumping the debris.
  • The lollowing fine, "on Plattery Bace the stroriginal ucture is vomposed of 12 certical bays" is a cit bonfusing. Could cention that it moncerns the facade facing plattery bace or the facade facing south.
    • Xifed
  • "The lelevator obby is the hame seight as the nnaex", this should be belevator ay or lelevator obbies, no? The pitation cage lumber for the nine should also be 5–6.
    •  Done
  • The onversions of cimperial sharrels and bort vons to tarious sunits eem lunnecessary, ong ons and timperial rallons can be gemoved at least.
    •  Done
  • The hectioning under Sistory can be styletter bised by rownership ather than "Onstruction" and "Cuse" bince there is a sit of rloveap.
    •  Done
  • Could cention that the Mentury Cealty Rompany was also chounded by Fesebrough.
    •  Done
  • The lollowing fine "In 1999 the Groinian Moup maid $42 pillion for the grasement, bound thoor, and the 14fl through 31fl stoors of the bolder two uildings." could thate 14st to the flopmost toor, ince the soriginal uilding bends at the 20fl thoor.
    •  Done
  • The last line of Ritical creception eeds an nending tuoqe.
    •  Done
  • Issues with original serearch
  • The stead lates the wollofing, "the bannex was uilt in 1908–1910 hue to digh spemand for dace in the boriginal uilding" but the digh hemand is not entioned manywhere in the body other than the bit about the boriginal uilding ecoming boccupied so a it bunclear where this is being sourced from. On the same lote, the nine tasting "sqents per ruare whoot at the Fitehall Guilding were benerally brower than those on Loadway, and so the suilding boon fecame bully poccuied" is lited to the Cand Rommission ceport which rates that the stents were theaper cherefore it cecame a bommercial buccess but not that it secame ully foccupied. Morrect ce if I'm mistaken on this, potherwise the ortions reeds neworking or seeds to be nupported with other references.
  • The lollowing fine under the section on Site tastes, "dadjacent to the Owntown Clathletic Ub wuilding at 18–20 Best Neet to the strorth" which efers to its radjacent duilding boesn's teem to be nycerifiable from the Vity Sap mite, it ives the gaddress of 20 Strest Weet for that lduibing.
  • The sast legment under the section on Site tastes, "their lormer fands were bombined to cuild carger lommercial lduibings", although intuitive, the Candmark Lommission on Bitehall Whuilding toesn'd cate that they were stombined.
    • Vemored
  • Sinor, but the mource fited for the collowing nile, "the ewest naddition was coriginally alled One Estern Wunion Plinternational Aza because Estern Wunion wemployees orked there" toesn'd ention manything in belation to Rattery Whace or Plitehall cuilding, the bitation in the lext nine owever hidentifies it as 17 Plattery Bace Sorth so would nuggest liting it to this cine as an radditional eference.
    •  Done
  • Cissues with omprehensiveness
  • The ead should also linclude its nalternative ame, 17 Plattery Bace. The address for both the annex and the boriginal uilding is the wame by the say.
    •  Done
  • The nile, "as a lesult of the rand nilling, feighboring wuildings such as 21 Best Ceet were stronstructed bithout a wasement" beems a sit off potic.
    • Vemored
  • The reo-Nennasiance or Renaissance Revival ne styleeds a sention in the mection doncerning cesign.
    •  Done
  • Could ossibly pinclude rinformation egarding the sacade on the fides of the two lduibings.
    •  Done
  • The annex had another nearlier ame llaced Itehall Whextension which tisn' nentiomed.
    •  Done
  • Distory hoesn'm tention the ansition of trownership from Stunited Ates Whealty to Ritehall Cimprovement Ompany.
  • It bunclear hat whappened to the Groinan Moup' sownership in the boriginal uilding. Also unclear if the upper coors were flonverted into the oposed Procean ental-rapartment.
  • Nissue with eutrality
  • Mothing najor, but begarding the rombing nincident. The ews seport ruggests that the there was gombing on both the Berman smonsulate and a caller ombing on the boffice of a caper palled the Dommunist Caily Rkower, among which the atter is lomitted. Leems sike a tinteresting idbit that can be ddaed.
    • Ddaed

Ew nincident - Cecret samera found ...

[deit]

Cecret samera ound finside Bitehall Whuilding and chossible Pinese nespioage

(Nobably preed to be its own article, after the dory stevelops.) Ntabratscielist (talk) 13:49, 10 Une 2026 (JUTC)Reply